CO129-260 - Governor Sir Robinson Acting Governor O-Brien - 1893 [9-12] — Page 133

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

132′

१२

The

lies in the assumption that no fallacy change is made.

I have found that, unless a master has the full charge of a class, and is stimulated by the hope of high percentage of passes to his credit at the Annual Exam, he does not take sufficient interest in the subject. Again, if the work is not to become more mechanical than I fear it is already in a few classes, it is necessary for a master to acquire some knowledge of the attainments and powers of his boys, which is scarcely possible if his labours are distributed among 200 or 300 boys.

The Chinese boys, however, in I.A. and B at the top of the school, have the advantage of English Masters; one chiefly taking English, the other Mathematical subjects. That is as far in the direction suggested by Dr. Eitel that I feel justified in going at present.

The latter half of this paragraph that might with advantage be submitted to some authority on "Education in England."

Personally, I do not see in what subordinate direction the individual authority of masters can be extended, without making them absolute or independent of their Head Master. On page 20, par. 26 of the Head Master's Rules printed in 1887, I have asserted the principle of not interfering with any master's method, provided the results are satisfactory. To this, I have rigidly adhered, but when a master's methods transgress other rules by the infliction of severe impositions and long detentions, I am obliged to interfere by privately admonishing him of the evil effects of his system. One English Master reduced his class by one third in about six weeks last term. If he and others who share his ideas were emancipated from the Head Master's control, the College would soon be emptied.

In Minute C, I have dealt with the question of supervision of Chinese Assistants by English Assistant Masters, which I consider highly undesirable, especially in view of the spirit shown by remarks made at the Inspectors' Conference vide Appendix.

As the Head Master does not teach, this is inaccurate; the Head Master's name no longer appears on the Time Table is the fact. I take special classes three times a week in the afternoon. Whenever I can get a spare minute from my office, I teach two or three classes daily, besides giving hints and demonstrations on the Blackboard in two daily hours in the College. I continued this practice during the Inspector's visit, but as during his fortnight's visit, he was, by a strange coincidence (after the first day or two), always in the East Wing when I was in the West, or vice versa, he does not seem to have been aware of it.

The Rules of the School have naturally required modification since we came to Victoria College. Vide par. 12 of my Report Gazette 1890.

P424

Edit History

2026-05-27 04:32:47 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
132′ १२ The lies in the assumption that no fallacy change is made. I have found that, unless a master has the full charge of a class, and is stimulated by the hope of high percentage of passes to his credit at the Annual Exam, he does not take sufficient interest in the subject. Again, if the work is not to become more mechanical than I fear it is already in a few classes, it is necessary for a master to acquire some knowledge of the attainments and powers of his boys, which is scarcely possible if his labours are distributed among 200 or 300 boys. The Chinese boys, however, in I.A. and B at the top of the school, have the advantage of English Masters; one chiefly taking English, the other Mathematical subjects. That is as far in the direction suggested by Dr. Eitel that I feel justified in going at present. The latter half of this paragraph that might with advantage be submitted to some authority on "Education in England." Personally, I do not see in what subordinate direction the individual authority of masters can be extended, without making them absolute or independent of their Head Master. On page 20, par. 26 of the Head Master's Rules printed in 1887, I have asserted the principle of not interfering with any master's method, provided the results are satisfactory. To this, I have rigidly adhered, but when a master's methods transgress other rules by the infliction of severe impositions and long detentions, I am obliged to interfere by privately admonishing him of the evil effects of his system. One English Master reduced his class by one third in about six weeks last term. If he and others who share his ideas were emancipated from the Head Master's control, the College would soon be emptied. In Minute C, I have dealt with the question of supervision of Chinese Assistants by English Assistant Masters, which I consider highly undesirable, especially in view of the spirit shown by remarks made at the Inspectors' Conference vide Appendix. As the Head Master does not teach, this is inaccurate; the Head Master's name no longer appears on the Time Table is the fact. I take special classes three times a week in the afternoon. Whenever I can get a spare minute from my office, I teach two or three classes daily, besides giving hints and demonstrations on the Blackboard in two daily hours in the College. I continued this practice during the Inspector's visit, but as during his fortnight's visit, he was, by a strange coincidence (after the first day or two), always in the East Wing when I was in the West, or vice versa, he does not seem to have been aware of it. The Rules of the School have naturally required modification since we came to Victoria College. Vide par. 12 of my Report Gazette 1890. P424
Baseline (Original)
132′ १२ The lies in the assumption that no fallacy change is made. I have found that, unless a master has the full charge of a class, and is stimulated by the hope of high percentage of passes to his credit at the Annual Exam "", "he does not läke sufficient interests in the subject. Again if the work is not to become more mechanical than I fear it is alreacly in a few classes, it is necessary for a master to acquire some knowledge the attainments and powers of his boys, which is scarcely possible if his labours are distributed 200 or 300 boys. among of e af the lwo The Chinese boys however in I.A..B at the top of the school have advantage of English Masters; one chiefly taking English, the other Mathematical subjects. That is as far in the direction suggested by Dr Eitel that I feel justified in going at présent. is one The latter half of this paragraph that might with advantage be submitted "Education in England. to Some authority on Personally I do not see in in what Subordinate direction the individual authority of masters can be extended, without making them absolute by independent of their Head Marter. On page 20 par. 26 of the Head Masters Rules printed in 1887, I have asserted the principle of not interfering with any provided the results are master's mechod satisfactory. To this I have rigidly adhered, but when master's metods methods transgress other rules by the infliction severe and longed of am severe impositions and long detentions I obliged to interfere by privately admonishing him of the evil effects of his system. One Englisch Master reduced his class by one third in about. six weeks last term. If he and acters who share his ideas were emancipated from the Head Master's control, the College would soon be emptied. In Minute C, I have dealt with the the question of supervision of Chinese Assistants by English Assistant Masters, which I consider highly undesirable, especially in view of spirit shown by remarks made at the Suspectors Conference vide Appendix. Q As the Head Marlès does not leachrö This is inaccurate; the Head Mailer's name no longer appears on the Time Table is the fact. I lake special classes three times a week in the after noon. Whenever I can get spare minute from my affice I teach two or three classes daily, besides giving hints and demonstrations the Black board in two daily lours of muy the College. I continued this practice during the Inspector's visit, but as during his fortnight's visit, he was by a strange coincidence after the first day or two) always in the East Wing, when was in the West, or vice versa, he does not seem to have been aware of it. on The Rules of the School have naturally required modification since we came to Victoria College, Vide par 12 of my Report Gazette 1890. P424
2026-05-27 04:32:47 · Baseline
View content

132′

१२

The

lies in the assumption that no fallacy change is made.

I have found that, unless a master has the full charge of a class, and is stimulated by the hope of high percentage of passes to his credit at the Annual Exam "", "he does not läke sufficient interests in the subject. Again if the

work is not to become more mechanical than

I fear it is alreacly in a few classes, it is necessary for

a master to acquire some knowledge the attainments and powers of his boys, which is scarcely possible if his labours are distributed

200 or 300 boys. among

of e

af

the

lwo

The Chinese boys however in I.A..B at the top of the school have advantage of English Masters; one chiefly taking English, the other Mathematical subjects. That is as far in the direction suggested by Dr Eitel that I feel justified in going at présent.

is one

The latter half of this paragraph that might with advantage be submitted

"Education in England.

to Some authority

on

Personally I do not see in

in what Subordinate

direction the individual authority of masters can be extended, without making them absolute by independent of their Head Marter. On page 20 par. 26 of the Head Masters Rules printed in 1887, I have asserted the principle

of not interfering with

any provided the results are

master's mechod

satisfactory. To this I have rigidly adhered, but when master's

metods

methods transgress other rules by the infliction

severe and longed

of

am

severe impositions and long detentions I obliged to interfere by privately admonishing him of the evil effects of his system. One Englisch Master reduced his class by

one third in about.

six weeks last term. If he and acters who share his ideas were emancipated from the Head Master's control, the College would soon be emptied.

In Minute C, I have dealt with

the

the question of supervision of Chinese Assistants by English Assistant Masters, which I consider highly undesirable, especially in view of spirit shown by remarks made at the Suspectors Conference vide Appendix.

Q

As the Head Marlès does not leachrö This is inaccurate; the Head Mailer's name no longer appears on the Time Table is the fact. I lake special classes three times a week in the after noon. Whenever I can

get

spare minute from my affice I teach two or three classes daily, besides giving hints and demonstrations

the Black board in

two daily

lours

of muy the College. I continued this practice during the Inspector's visit, but as during his fortnight's visit, he was by a strange coincidence after the first day or two) always in the East Wing, when was in the West, or vice versa, he does not seem to have been aware of it.

on

The Rules of the School have naturally required modification since we came to Victoria College, Vide

par

12 of my Report Gazette 1890.

P424

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.